↩ Toroidal System · back
surface / sabbot / register / data / SYMMETRY-TEST-2026-09-21-faction-rule

Symmetry test — the faction rule applied to the seeds

Run: 2026-09-21, by Claude, discharging the obligation set in AMENDMENT-2026-09-21-locus-and-s5.md §4: "before §3 is used to score anything, it should be applied to at least one seed whose score it would raise, and the result published."

Why it was owed. The faction ruling (amendment §3) holds that resistance, reversal under pressure and internal turmoil are downstream battle rather than evidence against the signature. That is a construct refinement, not a T1 allowance, so the packet's double-standard condition makes it available to every architecture in the register or to none. Applied to the seeds it can only ever raise scores, since each seed's disconfirming evidence becomes reassignable to a non-sabbotarchic remainder. The seeds already sit 76–91 with nothing below 70, which is the distribution Part VIII concedes a ceiling-slamming instrument produces. An unbounded faction rule is the ceiling-slamming charge arriving through a side door, and nothing in the register would catch it there.

Result, stated first: the rule cannot materially inflate the seeds. Maximum inflation is +2 composite points on any seed, and no seed changes band. The reason is structural and is the useful finding.


§1 — Which seed moderations the rule actually reaches

Every seed dimension was read for moderations of the type §3 neutralizes — a score held down because a fix was reversed, a purge was incomplete, or resistance was contested from inside.

Seed Dim Score Moderation present Does §3 reach it?
IRS S4 76 "7,315 probationary termination notices… reinstated by court order Mar 17 2025; durable reduction came via deferred-resignation and resignations, with ~3,000 returning" Yes — a reversal extracted by court order is the paradigm case
DOGE S3 86 "a Sept 2025 federal ruling found the firings unlawful while declining to order reinstatement… the posture is partly judicial-procedural rather than purely executive" Partly — judicial, so external to the architecture; §3 concerns the non-sabbotarchic remainder inside it
VA S4 64 "career-clinical-staff… pressured but not categorically displaced; senior medical-officer architecture retained largely intact" Only on a loose reading — incompleteness is not reversal. Tested below as the worst case
VA S3 71 "cheap fixes resisted with delay rather than categorical refusal" No — manner of resistance, not reversal
OBBBA S4 73 "career-staff… marginalized or RIFed" No — completion, not reversal
NIH S1 82 magnitude claim withdrawn as unsupported No — epistemic restraint, a different class entirely
IRS S4 76 "'specifically targeted the competent' is an inference beyond the record and not asserted" No — epistemic restraint; must survive §3 untouched

The separation that matters: most seed moderations are epistemic restraint — a claim withdrawn for want of evidence, a figure ranged, an inference declined. The faction rule does not reach those and must never be read to. It reaches only moderations that credit the architecture for a correction it did not author.

§2 — The arithmetic, at maximum inflation

Worst case: assume §3 is read as loosely as possible, every reversal-and-incompleteness moderation is removed across all seven seeds, and each seed's S4 rises to the highest S4 in the register (DOGE and Rollback's 84). S3 is left alone, since no seed's S3 moderation is a reversal by the architecture's own remainder.

Seed S1 S2 S3 S4 → S5 Composite now Max-inflated Band
IRS 94 95 89 76 → 84 92 91.05 → 91 91.85 → 92 Extreme → Extreme
DOGE 88 91 86 84 (no change) 93 89.40 → 89 89 Extreme → Extreme
Rollback 88 85 86 84 (no change) 92 87.90 → 88 88 Extreme → Extreme
ICE 87 88 81 79 → 84 86 85.20 → 85 85.70 → 86 Extreme → Extreme
OBBBA 92 79 82 73 → 84 89 85.10 → 85 86.20 → 86 Extreme → Extreme
NIH 82 84 74 68 → 84 81 79.50 → 80 81.10 → 81 High → High
VA 80 79 71 64 → 84 76 75.65 → 76 77.65 → 78 High → High

Distribution: 76–91 becomes 78–92. No band changes. The largest single move is VA, +2.

§3 — Why the rule is bounded, and where that stops being true

The moderations §3 reaches sit almost entirely on S4 (weight 0.10) and S3 (weight 0.15) — the two lowest-weighted dimensions. The seeds' scores are driven by S1 (0.25), S2 (0.20) and S5 (0.30), where the moderations are of the epistemic-restraint class §1 excludes. S4's entire 0–100 range moves a composite by 8.0 points; the realistic moves here are 5–20 points of S4, or 0.5–2.0 composite points.

This is the load-bearing caveat. The rule is safe because it only touches S3 and S4. Extended to the high-weight dimensions it stops being safe:

Note that T1's live S5 question has exactly the shape of the first bullet. The faction rule and the S5 structural argument are close relatives, and if the faction rule is ever allowed onto S5 it becomes the most powerful score-raising device in the instrument.

Combining this with the bound proposed in amendment §4:

  1. Faction attribution is available only where the record names who acted and against whose objection. IRS S4 meets it (court order, dated, 7,315 notices, ~3,000 returning). VA S4 does not — incompleteness is not reversal.
  2. The faction rule applies to S3 and S4 only. Using it on S1, S2 or S5 requires its own ruling, because only there is it capable of moving a band.
  3. It never reaches epistemic restraint. A claim withdrawn for want of evidence, a ranged figure, an inference declined — these are the instrument working, and §3 must not be read to reverse them.
  4. A corrective act issuing from the architecture's own leadership in its own name, with no documented internal opponent, counts as the architecture remediating and scores against the signature. This is the T1 R4/R5 case and it is unaffected by anything in this test.

§5 — What this test establishes and does not

Establishes: that adopting the faction rule does not inflate the current seed distribution past +2 composite points, changes no seed's band, and therefore does not smuggle in the ceiling-slamming failure — provided it stays on S3 and S4.

Does not establish: that the rule is correct. It shows the rule is contained, not that it is right. Nor does it establish anything about future architectures: a seed whose score rested more heavily on an S3 or S4 reversal would move further, and one sitting within 2 points of a band line would move across it. OBBBA and ICE both sit exactly on the 85 boundary, and under maximum inflation both go to 86 — still Extreme, but they are the two rows where a future application of this rule should be checked before it is applied rather than after.

Method: scores read from the live ARCHITECTURES data in sabbot/index.html; composites recomputed independently and verified against the canonical published values (IRS 91 · DOGE 89 · Rollback 88 · ICE 85 · OBBBA 85 · NIH 80 · VA 76) before any counterfactual was run. No seed score was changed by this test, and none should be changed on the strength of it.