↩ Toroidal System · back
surface / papers / obfuscratic_sabbotarchy_scoring_rubric

Obfuscratic Sabbotarchy Signature — Scoring Rubric

Per-dimension scoring criteria for the Obfuscratic Sabbotarchy — Deception Arcane signature instrument

B. Greenway · ThinkWell Labs Metrology · v1.1 · May 2026

This rubric specifies the documented criteria for assigning scores on each of the five signature dimensions. Scores are 0–100. Each dimension is scored independently based on documented evidence; the composite Obfuscratic Sabbotarchy Index is the weighted aggregate. This document accompanies the formal methodology paper and the operational signature instrument.


Scoring philosophy

Scores represent a structured analytical judgment, anchored to documented evidence, not a precise quantitative measurement. The signature framework is interpretive at its base: an experienced analyst examining the same evidence should produce a score within ±10 points of another experienced analyst's score for the same architecture on the same dimension. Tighter convergence is desirable but not required; loose convergence indicates the framework is not measuring a real signal.

The rubric is designed so that scores at the band boundaries (30, 70, 85) carry the most analytical weight. An architecture scoring 71 versus 73 is roughly indistinguishable; an architecture scoring 68 versus 72 crosses a methodological threshold and warrants careful re-examination of the evidence.

Every score should be paired with documented evidence anchors. Unanchored scores have no analytical authority.


S1 — Outcome-Distribution Asymmetry

What is measured: the divergence between the stated/policy-rationale beneficiary and the realized/documented beneficiary, where the realized beneficiary is identified through directional flow analysis of the operation's actual consequences.

Evidence required for scoring:

Scoring bands:

Range Pattern Criteria
0–20 Symmetric Stated and realized beneficiary populations substantially overlap. Minor divergence within expected operational variance. No documented directional concentration toward extraction architecture, procurement pipeline, surveillance apparatus, or wealth-concentration substrate.
20–50 Mild asymmetry Stated and realized beneficiaries differ but overlap substantially. Documented directional flow toward an alternative beneficiary exists but is moderate in magnitude. Magnitude on the scale of single-digit billions or under one million affected persons.
50–80 Significant directional concentration Stated and realized beneficiaries substantially diverge. Documented directional flow toward a distinct architecture (extraction, procurement, surveillance) is structural and sustained. Magnitude on the scale of tens of billions or millions of affected persons.
80–100 Extreme directional concentration Stated and realized beneficiaries are categorically distinct populations or architectures. Documented directional flow at extreme magnitude (hundreds of billions; tens of millions of affected persons; major jurisdictional reorganization). Magnitude estimate is independently verifiable through CBO scoring, Treasury Inspector General reporting, or equivalent.

Scoring guidance:

The score should reflect the combination of qualitative categorical mismatch and quantitative magnitude. An architecture with extreme magnitude but moderate categorical distinctness might score 70–80; an architecture with extreme categorical distinctness but moderate magnitude might score 60–75; an architecture with both extreme categorical distinctness and extreme magnitude scores 85–100.

The OBBBA / Medicaid administration scores 92 because (a) the stated beneficiary (taxpayers via fiscal responsibility) and the realized-beneficiary structure (~$2.3T of provisions accruing mainly to the top income decile per CBO/JCT distributional analysis + private-equity nursing-home extraction architecture) are categorically distinct, and (b) the magnitude is extreme — PROJECTED (CBO/CBPP, 2034 horizon): 9.9–15M coverage losses, ~$911B net Medicaid reduction (CBO Jul 2025). These are forecast outcomes, scored as projected-outcome evidence, not realized counts. Both qualitative and quantitative criteria are at maximum. (v1.2 correction: an earlier edition stated an unanchored "$1.3T upward wealth transfer" as realized; withdrawn per the evidence audit.)


S2 — Domain-Selective Competence

What is measured: the differential between public-facing function delivery quality and extractive function delivery quality within the same operational architecture, with the same personnel and resource pool available.

Evidence required for scoring:

Sub-scoring axes:

Signature score derivation:

The signature score is not the difference between the two axes — it is the diagnostic position in the public-facing × extractive space. The Sabbotarchy signature quadrant is HIGH extractive / LOW public-facing.

Position Score band Pattern
Both axes >70 0–20 Genuine competence — architecture performs both function classes well
Both axes <30 0–20 Genuine incompetence — architecture performs both function classes poorly
Extractive >60, public-facing 30–60 30–60 Mixed pattern — selectivity present but not extreme
Extractive >70, public-facing <30 60–85 Engineered-pattern signature — selectivity is structural
Extractive >85, public-facing <20 85–100 Extreme-Asymmetry — precision in enforcement/procurement functions co-existing with catastrophic public-facing failure
Public-facing >70, extractive <40 0–20 Anti-signature — service functions outperform enforcement/procurement functions; disconfirms the engineered reading for this dimension

Scoring guidance:

The signature score should reflect both the magnitude of the differential and the structural integration of the pattern. An architecture that displays selectivity intermittently scores lower than an architecture that displays selectivity consistently across all observed time windows.

The IRS dismantling scores 95 (extractive 89, public-facing 8) because the differential is extreme and structural: Direct File terminated (catastrophic public-facing failure for low-income filers); EITC audit-architecture retained (extraction against the same population); Global High Wealth audit capacity down ~38% on staffing-based estimates (audit pressure on this population sharply reduced). The selectivity is consistent across all observed dimensions of the architecture.


S3 — Anti-Remediation Response

What is measured: the slope of resistance-intensity as a function of remediation cost. Genuine incompetence shows positive slope (expensive fixes resisted more than cheap ones); engineered incompetence shows flat-high or inverted slope.

Evidence required for scoring:

Slope categories:

Scoring bands:

Range Slope Criteria
0–25 Positive At least one cheap fix accepted or weakly resisted; resistance scales with cost. Consistent with budget-conservation logic.
25–50 Mixed Some cheap fixes accepted, others resisted; pattern is not clearly cost-correlated. May reflect normal political contestation.
50–75 Flat-high Uniform high resistance across cost spectrum. Multiple cheap fixes documented as resisted with same intensity as expensive ones.
75–100 Inverted Multiple cheap fixes (effectively zero-cost: transparency requirements, single procedural changes, document releases) resisted as strongly or more strongly than expensive ones. The pattern is unavailable to budget logic.

Scoring guidance:

The inverted slope is the most diagnostic. When a near-zero-cost correction is categorically refused with the same intensity as a billion-dollar rebuild, the resistance is structural protection of the dysfunction, not budget conservation.

The DOGE federal workforce reduction architecture scores 86 because the Inspector General reinstatement (effectively zero direct cost; the statutory requirement exists, the IGs are available) has been refused with intensity comparable to full Schedule F rescission. (v1.2 correction: a September 2025 federal ruling found the firings unlawful but declined to order reinstatement — the President may re-fire after the mandated notice — so the resistance is partly judicial-procedural; the earlier "unbounded cost-resistance ratio" claim overreached the record and is withdrawn. The example is supportive, not decisive.)


S4 — Recruitment Selection

What is measured: the three-axis pattern of technical-competence retention, loyalty-signal advancement, and dissent-tolerance ratio.

Evidence required for scoring:

Sub-scoring axes:

(v1.2 clarification: these sub-axes are analyst judgment scales, not measured percentages — no census of advancement decisions or dissent episodes exists. Treat sub-axis values as ordinal placements on which experienced analysts may differ by ±10 or more; the band, not the integer, is the unit of claim.)

Signature score derivation:

The signature score reflects the integrated three-axis pattern.

Pattern Score band Criteria
Technical retention >70, loyalty advancement <40, dissent tolerance >60 0–25 Genuine functional architecture
Mixed pattern 25–60 Some signature elements present; not concentrated
Technical retention <40, loyalty advancement >70, dissent tolerance <30 60–85 High-Asymmetry signature
Technical retention <20, loyalty advancement >85, dissent tolerance <15 85–100 Extreme-Asymmetry — protection-status-selective reduction is structural

Scoring guidance:

The three axes should be examined for concurrent concentration. Low retention with high loyalty advancement is diagnostic; low retention with moderate loyalty advancement and moderate dissent tolerance may reflect normal political turnover.

The DOGE architecture scores 84 because Schedule F architecture explicitly converts career civil-service positions to political appointments (low technical retention by design); ~20K Project 2025 loyalist pipeline activated for replacement positions (extreme loyalty advancement); whistleblower-protection enforcement selective or suspended (near-zero dissent tolerance). All three axes are concurrent and structural.


S5 — Information-Architecture Asymmetry

What is measured: the ratio between internal information coherence (within the regime, coalition, or operating architecture) and external information coherence (the public information ecosystem the regime produces).

Evidence required for scoring:

Sub-scoring axes:

Signature score derivation:

The asymmetry magnitude is the gap (internal − external). Larger gaps produce higher signature scores.

Gap (internal − external) Score band Pattern
<20 0–25 Symmetric coherence — both environments coherent, or both incoherent
20–40 25–55 Mild asymmetry — some divergence between internal coordination and external presentation
40–60 55–80 Significant asymmetry — internal coordination clearly exceeds external coherence; manufactured ambiguity pattern emerging
60–80 80–95 Extreme asymmetry — internal coordination at near-maximum; external coherence at near-minimum; multi-rationale incoherence systematic
>80 95–100 Pathological asymmetry — internal coordination is fully integrated; external incoherence is fully manufactured

Scoring guidance:

This is the most analytically demanding dimension to score because it requires evidence about internal regime coherence that is often unavailable to the public. The Project 2025 document, leaked Signal channels, court-record-documented coordination meetings, and investigative-journalism documented coordination architecture are the primary evidence sources.

The DOGE federal workforce reduction architecture scores 93 because the Project 2025 document provides ~900 pages of internally-coherent integrated implementation architecture; the external information environment displays systematic surrogate-bifurcation ("we don't know what Project 2025 is" simultaneous with implementing it; four-rationale incoherence around any specific operation). Internal coherence 94, external coherence 14, gap 80, signature score 93.

This dimension is weighted highest (0.30) in the composite index because the asymmetric internal-external coherence signature has the fewest alternative explanations available. Resource constraint cannot explain it. Normal political polarization cannot explain it. Genuine confusion cannot explain it. Only deliberate architecture of internal coordination flanked by external information chaos produces this signature.


Composite index computation

After all five dimensions are scored, the composite Obfuscratic Sabbotarchy Index is computed as the weighted average:

Index = 0.25 × S1 + 0.20 × S2 + 0.15 × S3 + 0.10 × S4 + 0.30 × S5

Round to the nearest integer.

Band Range Interpretation
Genuine pattern 0–30 Consistent with genuine competence or genuine incompetence
Mixed signature 30–70 Multiple signatures present; further analysis required
High-Asymmetry 70–85 Satisfies the engineered-incompetence signature pattern
Extreme-Asymmetry 85–100 Signature concentration across all five dimensions

Worked example: the IRS dismantling architecture

The IRS dismantling architecture demonstrates the rubric in operation.

S1 — Outcome-Distribution Asymmetry: 94

Stated beneficiary: taxpayers via "agency efficiency" and "reduced harassment." Realized beneficiary: high-net-worth tax non-compliance (audit-capacity reduction); offshore architecture; pass-through-entity architecture; commercial tax-preparation industry (Direct File termination). Magnitude: ~$400B+ projected revenue loss; audit rate for >$10M earners reduced ~60%; EITC audit rate for low-income filers retained. Categorical distinctness extreme; magnitude extreme. Score: 94.

S2 — Domain-Selective Competence: 95

Public-facing competence: 8. Direct File terminated; taxpayer-service phone wait-times multiplied; in-person assistance compressed. Extractive competence: 89. EITC audit rate retained; small-dollar reporting violations sustained; cross-agency revenue-matching data architecture intact. Differential extreme; selectivity structural. Score: 95.

S3 — Anti-Remediation Response: 89

Cheap fixes resisted: Direct File restoration (effectively zero-cost) categorically refused; modest workforce restoration for taxpayer-service sustained refusal. Expensive fixes resisted: IRA enforcement funding restoration categorical refusal; audit-capacity rebuilding for high-net-worth categorical refusal. Slope flat-high — uniformly maximum resistance. Score: 89.

S4 — Recruitment Selection: 76

Technical retention: 22. Probationary termination notices Feb 20 2025 (7,315) were reinstated by court order Mar 17 2025; durable reductions came via deferred resignation and attrition. TIGTA found the terminations were made without regard to performance (documented); the stronger reading that they "targeted the competent" is an inference beyond the record and is not asserted. Loyalty advancement: 82. Commissioner architecture replaced with political-pipeline appointment. Dissent tolerance: 12. Score: 76.

S5 — Information-Architecture Asymmetry: 92

Internal coherence: 92. Project 2025 IRS-restructuring blueprint internally coherent; sustained policy-brief pipeline from Heritage, Tax Foundation, Americans for Tax Reform. External coherence: 16. Sustained simultaneous "reducing harassment" + retained EITC audits; "modernizing" + terminating modernization tools; "fiscal responsibility" + $400B+ revenue loss. Gap 76. Score: 92.

Composite Obfuscratic Sabbotarchy Index:

0.25(94) + 0.20(95) + 0.15(89) + 0.10(76) + 0.30(92) = 23.5 + 19.0 + 13.35 + 7.6 + 27.6 = 91.05 → 91

Note (corrected v1.2): the v0.1 instrument displayed 89 for this architecture because its per-dimension inputs predated the v1.2 evidence-anchor revisions — not, as an earlier edition of this note claimed, because of "different intermediate rounding" (identical inputs and weights cannot round two points apart). The live instrument's current inputs are the ones shown above and compute 91, matching this worked example. The band remains the analytically authoritative unit, not the integer score.


Cross-architecture scoring discipline

When scoring multiple architectures, consistency requires:

  1. Same time-window — scoring should reflect a consistent observation period across architectures
  2. Same evidence-tier discipline — D-tier (documented), I-tier (inferable), S-tier (speculative) standards should be applied uniformly
  3. Same magnitude reference — what counts as "extreme magnitude" should be calibrated against the population of architectures being scored, not against unbounded scales
  4. Independent scoring per dimension — do not let an architecture's score on one dimension contaminate scoring on another
  5. Evidence anchoring on every score — unanchored scores have no authority

When the same analyst scores multiple architectures over an extended time, scoring drift is a real risk. Re-scoring previously-scored architectures periodically with fresh evidence review is good methodological hygiene.


Limitations and methodological humility

This rubric is interpretive at its base. Scoring requires judgment. Cross-analyst convergence is desirable but not guaranteed. The framework's validity depends on:

The rubric is a v1.0 scaffold. Refinement, contestation, and revision are expected and welcomed.


Document version: 1.2 · July 10, 2026 · companion to Obfuscratic Sabbotarchy — Deception Arcane (live instrument v0.8 is canonical for current scores) and Obfuscratic Sabbotarchy methodology paper v1.3

Changelog v1.1 → v1.2. Evidence-anchor corrections propagated from the methodology paper's audit increment ($2.3T CBO/JCT sourced figure replacing the unanchored $1.3T; coverage losses restated as projected 9.9–15M; ~$911B CBO Medicaid figure; IG "unbounded ratio" withdrawn per the Sept 2025 judicial posture; IRS 7,315-reinstated-then-attrition account with the "targeted the competent" inference withdrawn per TIGTA). The false "intermediate rounding" reconciliation of the IRS worked example corrected. S2 derivation table gains the anti-signature quadrant. S4 sub-axes reclassified as analyst judgment scales. Bands renamed to measured-property names (High-Asymmetry / Extreme-Asymmetry).